FIELD NOTES BLOG

The Mystery of Transient Luminous Events

November 22, 2024

Hundreds of thousands of feet above us there is a mysterious world of elves, sprites, pixes, trolls, and gnomes. I’m not talking about middle earth, but about the rare phenomenon of transient luminous events (TLEs). TLEs are electrical discharges similar to lightning that occur in the upper atmosphere miles above thunderstorms. These mystifying electrical events are so beautiful and elusive that scientists couldn’t help but give them equally mythical names. In this blog we’ll explore the science of these nearly magical events, the questions that are still baffling scientists, how you can photograph them to contribute to community science, and what we can do to reduce light pollution to keep our skies magical.

Lightning

Before we dig into the strange phenomena of transient luminous events, let’s cover the basics of the lightning we see regularly. Lightning occurs when opposite charges build up in storm clouds. The top of the cloud becomes positively charged, and the middle of the cloud becomes negatively charged. 

When enough opposite charges build up, air quickly changes from an insulator, something that prevents electricity from moving, to a conductor, something that electricity can move through. At this point electricity is discharged through the air to equalize the charges. Lightning can travel within a cloud, between two clouds, or between clouds and the ground. Lightning can be grouped further based on if it is positive or negative.


Positive cloud to ground lightning is the most powerful form of lightning but also the rarest. It originates in the positively charged region at the top of storm clouds and travels to negatively charged regions in other clouds or in the ground. “Bolts from the blue” are a type of positive lightning that can travel more than 10 miles horizontally from storms before striking the ground. Positive lightning is also believed to be responsible for many forms of TLEs.


Transient Luminous Events

The existence of visible electrical discharges in the upper atmosphere was first theorized in 1924 by Scottish physicist Charles Thomson Rees Wilson in his article “The Electric Field of a Thundercloud and Some of Its Effects.” Wilson also recorded seeing what modern researchers believe could have been a spirit, a type of TLE. Despite Wilson’s work, the existence of upper atmospheric lightning was not widely accepted until 1989 when researcher R. C. Franz recorded two sprites on a camera that he left recording overnight. 


Since sprites were first recorded on camera, interest in upper atmospheric lightning has proliferated in the scientific community and by enthusiasts. This spotlight on the skies has led to the discovery of a slew of captivating electrical events that take place far above thunderstorms.

Sprites

Sprites are the most common and well researched TLE.. Sprites are massive electrical discharges stretching from around thirty-one miles above sea level up to around fifty-six miles. For scale Mt Everest’s summit is five and a half miles above sea level. Sprites are thought to last for only 90-300 ms, meaning that they are very hard to see with the naked eye. They appear red in color with tendrils coming down off a bright glowing area at the top of the formation.


The exact causes of sprites are still debated. Scientists have tied them to positive clouds to ground lightning strikes, as they seem to always occur shortly after these powerful strikes. It is thought that sprites may be caused by the electric field caused by these powerful strikes. Typically, an electric field is not strong enough to turn air from an insulator to a conductor, but at the high altitudes where sprites occur the thin air requires less energy to break down. Currently, further research is being conducted to understand more about the causes of sprites and what impact they may have on atmospheric chemistry including ozone concentrations.

Jets

Jets are TLEs that start at the top of thunderstorms and travel up into the upper atmosphere. There are three types of jets that have been identified: gigantic jets, blue jets, and blue starters. Jets are rarer than sprites and harder to capture on film, and thus we know even less about them. 


Blue jets look like quick eruptions of blue light from the top of storm clouds. They are theorized to be caused by breakdown between the positive top of the cloud and the negative “screening layer” that exists above the storm, and if there is enough potential difference between these two areas, then the discharge erupts up past the screening layer.


Blue starters are thought to be like blue jets that do not break through the screening layer. Despite being shorter than blue jets, blue starters are brighter.


Gigantic jets travel up much further than blue jets, reaching altitudes close to 60 miles. One theory of gigantic jet formation suggests that they start as a negative intracloud lightning flash at break out of the top of the cloud.


Elves

ELVES stands for Emission of Light and Very low frequency perturbations due to Electromagnetic pulse Sources. ELVES appear as red expanding rings far above storms. ELVES only last for a few milliseconds, so they are impossible to see with your naked eye and very hard to capture on film. Not much is known about what causes ELVES because of how hard they are to observe. They occur at around sixty miles above sea level at the bottom of the ionosphere.


Pixies

Pixies are small pinpoints of light that occur on the top of thunderstorms clouds. They only last about sixteen milliseconds, and their causes are not well understood.

Trolls and Ghosts

Trolls and ghosts are visual components that sometimes occur with sprites. Trolls are trails that appear shortly after sprites going back down to clouds. Ghosts are glowing green spots that sometimes appear at the top of sprites. These names have been given by enthusiasts not scientists, and not much research has been into why sprites sometimes have these elements to them.


The Impacts of Light Pollution

Light pollution happens when people change the amount of light outdoors from its natural level. Light pollution can impact wildlife, human health, and our ability to see the night sky including TLEs. Seeing TLEs requires you to be around 200 -300 miles from a storm with little to no light pollution in between you and the storm. Unfortunately, very few areas like this exist anymore which makes it hard to see TLEs without special equipment or traveling far distances. Paul Smith, renowned TLE photographer, believes that in the days before light pollution sprites and jets would have been much more common to see based on his experience tracking them.


Light pollution can be reduced by shading outdoor lights, using dimmer lights, and turning lights off at night. More information about reducing light pollution is available at darksky.org

Community Science

If you are interested in learning more about TLEs and potentially seeing them for yourself, NASA has created a community science program for the study of TLEs called Spiritacular. Observations of TLEs submitted by the community help scientists learn more about what causes TLEs, and what effects they may have. The website has resources on how to find and photograph sprites, elves, and jets, as well as a gallery of photos taken by other citizen scientists. Check out Spiritacular if you are interested in capturing these magnificent events and contributing to our shared understanding of them.


References

DarkSky International. (2024, September 11). DarkSky International. https://darksky.org/


Lyons, W., Nelson, T., Armstrong, R., Pasko, V., & Stanley, M. (2003). Upward Electrical Discharges From Thunderstorm Tops. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 84(4), 445–454. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/bams/84/4/bams-84-4-445.xml


NOAA. (n.d.). Lightning Basics. National Severe Storm Laboratory. Retrieved November 6, 2024, from https://www.nssl.noaa.gov/education/svrwx101/lightning/


Preoteasa, G. (2023, February 28). Chasing Sprites. AMS Weather Band. https://amsweatherband.org/index.cfm/weatherband/articles/chasing-sprites/


Spritacular. (n.d.). Spritacular. Spritacular. Retrieved November 6, 2024, from https://spritacular.org/about


Temming, M. (2024, March 20). Explainer: Sprites, jets, ELVES and other storm-powered lights. ScienceNewsExplores. https://www.snexplores.org/article/sprites-jets-elves-storm-powered-lights


Wilson, C. (1924). The Electric Field of a Thundercloud and Some of Its Effects. Proceedings of the Physical Society of London, 37(1), 32D-37D. https://web.archive.org/web/20140310135835/http://www.storm-t.iag.usp.br/pub/ACA0330/papers/Wilson_electricfield_thunderstorms_1924.pdf


RECENT ARTICLES

By Bruce Muench April 25, 2025
Forward:
By Rowan Mermel April 23, 2025
“Once you see it you can’t unsee it”
April 22, 2025
From the rugged peaks of the Rocky Mountains to golden desert canyons, the rolling prairies to the ancient, mist-shrouded Appalachian mountains — America is a land rich in many beauties. We are home to the towering redwoods of the west coast, sun-drenched coastlines in the south, and the deep blues of the Great Lakes that collectively hold the largest volume of freshwater on Earth. These wild places offer a kind of quiet that stirs the soul. This vast, varied land is what we proudly call “America the Beautiful.” And on Earth Day, this is the America we celebrate. We scroll through snapshots of National Parks, photos of mountain trails, canyon vistas, tidepools, and wildflower filled prairies. Maybe we've seen these places with our own eyes — maybe we carry them like a dream we hope to one day reach. We’ve all, in some way, been struck by the beauty of this land. As I write these words, I’m sitting at my desk looking out the window into the woodland of Severson Dells, watching the first green buds emerge, listening to the fluting whistles of returning songbirds. How lucky are we to live among such beauty? But that beauty is in danger. Today, mountaintops in Appalachia are being blown apart for coal, their peaks stripped and valleys buried in rubble. Ancient forests in the Pacific Northwest are leveled for lumber, their centuries-old trees felled in minutes. Oil rigs rise like metal skeletons in Alaska’s fragile tundra, while pipelines thread through sacred Indigenous lands and important wildlife corridors. Wetlands that once buffered our coastlines from hurricanes are drained and filled. Prairies, once stretching unbroken across the heart of the continent like an ocean of grass, are disappearing under pavement and plow. Our coastlines are receding. Our coral reefs, once vibrant, are dying, bleaching bone-white. Even here, outside my window, invasive honeysuckle strangles the understory where spring ephemerals once bloomed, and the chorus of birds is quieter than it used to be — a stark reminder that nearly one-third of North American bird populations have vanished in the past fifty years. But this isn’t a new story. Ours is not the first generation to witness the cost of ‘progress’. The tension between beauty and destruction has shaped this nation since the Industrial Revolution. And while the challenges we face today are daunting, they are not insurmountable. Every year, on April 22nd, we celebrate Earth Day – a day that itself was born from a moment not unlike our own. America of the 1950’s and 60’s is almost unrecognizable from the America we know today. In 1943, Los Angeles residents awoke one morning to skies so dark and chemical-laden they feared they were under a gas attack . It was smog. Just 5 years later, a lethal blanket of smog from zinc smelters in Pennsylvania killed 20 people in just three days . The Merrimack River in New Hampshire ran a different color each day , depending on what the local mills were dumping. And in 1969, Cleveland's Cuyahoga River — thick with oil and industrial waste — burst into flames , its smoke billowing four stories high. These weren’t isolated incidents. They were the symptoms of a larger crisis—one brought on by decades of industrial expansion with few, if any, environmental safeguards. At the same time that America was enjoying unprecedented prosperity, it was also polluting its air, poisoning its rivers, and sickening its people. The economy boomed, but the environmental consequences were growing harder to ignore. In 1962, a marine biologist named Rachel Carson published Silent Spring, a book that would become a cornerstone of the modern environmental movement. Carson’s work focused on the effects of chemical pesticides—especially DDT—on ecosystems and human health. She warned of a future without birdsong, where toxins accumulated in the food chain and sickened both wildlife and people. Silent Spring struck a chord. It didn’t just present scientific facts, it gave voice to a deep, growing unease. People were already noticing the changes around them: the absence of fireflies in summer, the increasing number of fish kills in local lakes, the haze that lingered over cities for days. Carson’s words helped connect the dots, and it didn’t just inform, it inspired, and from it spurred the beginning of the environmental movement. By the late 1960s, a wave of activism was sweeping the country. Young people were leading protests against the Vietnam War, civil rights leaders were marching for justice, and college campuses had become hotbeds of political energy. Watching this cultural shift with inspiration was Senator Gaylord Nelson of Wisconsin. A long-time advocate for environmental protection, Nelson saw how the antiwar movement had galvanized young people—and he wondered whether that same passion could be channeled into fighting a different kind of crisis: the growing threat to America’s air, water, and land. His sense of urgency only deepened in early 1969, when tragedy struck the California coast. A blowout at a Union Oil drilling platform off the coast of Santa Barbara spilled nearly 100,000 barrels of crude oil into the Pacific Ocean . Black sludge washed up on miles of pristine beaches. Seabirds lay dying under slicks of oil. Dolphins and seals washed ashore. The air reeked of petroleum for weeks. The images were devastating—and they were broadcast into homes across the nation. Senator Nelson knew the time to act was now. In November of that year, he announced plans for a "National Teach-In on the Crisis of the Environment" —a day when Americans would come together to learn, protest, and push for meaningful environmental change. This name was later changed to Earth Day, and the date chosen was April 22, 1970—strategically placed between spring break and final exams to ensure strong participation on college campuses.  To bring this ambitious vision to life, Nelson turned to Denis Hayes, a 25-year-old student activist. With Hayes’ help, a 7 month timeline, and a shoestring budget of just $124,000, Earth Day sparked an unprecedented nationwide movement. College campuses began planning teach-ins and events. Newspapers picked up the story. Civic groups, churches, and schools joined in. The momentum built quickly—and organically. Within a few months, the Earth Day idea had become a nationwide grassroots event supported by millions of people. Colleges campuses across the country organized “teach- ins”, and major newspapers were writing about Senator Nelson's ideas. Earth Day may have been Gaylord Nelson’s idea, but American citizens made it happen. “Earth Day worked because of the spontaneous response at the grassroots level,” reflected Gaylord Nelson. “It organized itself.” Historian Adam Rome would later call it “the most famous unknown event in modern American history.” On April 22, 1970, an estimated 20 million Americans—nearly 10% of the U.S. population at the time —participated in what remains the largest single-day political demonstration in the nation’s history. People from all walks of life gathered for marches, cleanups, rallies, and teach-ins. The message was clear: the environment mattered, and the public was ready to fight for it. What made Earth Day so powerful was not just its scale, but its unity. The movement crossed ideological lines. It was bipartisan, supported by both Democrats and Republicans. At a time of deep national division, Earth Day reminded Americans that the health of our planet is a shared responsibility—and a common cause. Even more remarkable is that this enormous, coordinated event was pulled off without the tools we rely on today. No social media. No email. No cell phones. Just passionate people, printed flyers, rotary phones, and the belief that change was possible. The success of Earth Day didn’t just move the public—it resonated with leaders in Washington, and led to real change. In just a few years, the United States went from having almost no federal environmental policy to enacting an environmental policy infrastructure strong enough to slow down the era of unregulated industrial sprawl to protect our planet and public health. The success of the first Earth Day led to the passage of some of the most important environmental legislation in American history, including: The Clean Air Act (1970) The Clean Water Act (1972) The Endangered Species Act (1973) President Richard Nixon oversaw the establishment of the Environmental Protection Agency and signed the above landmark environmental laws into effect. In a 1970 speech, Nixon captured the spirit of the moment with a message that still rings true today: “The great question of the seventies is, shall we surrender to our surroundings, or shall we make our peace with nature and begin to make reparations for the damage we have done to our air, to our land, and to our water? Restoring nature to its natural state is a cause beyond party and beyond factions. It has become a common cause of all the people of this country. It is a cause of particular concern to young Americans, because they, more than we, will reap the grim consequences of our failure to act on programs which are needed now if we are to prevent disaster later. Clean air, clean water, open spaces—these should once again be the birthright of every American. If we act now, they can be. We still think of air as free. But clean air is not free, and neither is clean water. The price tag on pollution control is high. Through our years of past carelessness we incurred a debt to nature, and now that debt is being called. ” In the years that followed the first Earth Day, America made progress—rivers stopped catching fire, cities began to breathe a little easier, and wildlife rebounded. But the work was never meant to end in the 1970s. Earth Day is a reminder that the environment is not a limitless resource, and that protecting it requires action, accountability, and cooperation. Fifty five years later we face new environmental challenges, but Earth day is a reminder of what we can accomplish when we come together, regardless of party or background, to protect the natural world we all share. Today, the landmark pieces of legislation that were established in the 1970’s are under threat. The first hit to the Clean Water Act was the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Sackett v. EPA, which significantly narrowed the Act's scope, limiting protections for wetlands and many streams. This ruling has led to a significant weakening of federal oversight. More recently, the EPA has announced significant changes to the Clean Water Act that potentially puts the drinking water sources for tens of millions of Americans at risk. As for the Endangered Species Act, there is a proposed rule change that would limit violations of the Act only to actions that hurt or kill animals. Harming the habitats the endangered animals need to survive would no longer be a violation of the Endangered Species Act, which would open large swaths of land to logging, mining and development that were previously protected. As we all know, if a species doesn’t have the habitat to survive and breed in then it will eventually go extinct. This proposed rule change is open for public comment until May 19 in the Federal Register, so please consider sharing your opinion . Additionally, there is the Zero-Based Regulatory Budgeting To Unleash American Energy Executive Order. The legal community is still trying to figure out just how far reaching this EO is, but it is likely to have a significant impact on a wide range of environmental regulations. These threats to the health of our environment put “America the Beautiful” at risk. The spacious skies, amber waves of grain, purple mountain majesties, and the fruited plain from sea to shining sea are left vulnerable. Now more than ever, Earth Day calls on all of us to act to protect our beautiful environment. Earth Day is now celebrated in over 190 countries. But its roots lie in a time when people refused to accept the destruction of the world around them as inevitable. So, what will you do this Earth Day? Because history has shown us: when people care, when they act together, the world changes. The debt to nature is still being called—and we still have the power to answer. This Earth Day, don’t just celebrate – participate. Plant a tree. Call your representatives. Learn the name of the bird outside your window. Donate to organizations that support our natural lands, our water, and our future. Vote. Teach your children not just to love the Earth, but to fight for it. Talk about climate change, even when it’s hard. Especially when it’s hard. Use your voice, use your art, use your science. Join a local cleanup, start a compost bin, reduce your plastic use. Talk to your neighbors. Talk to your parents. Talk to your children. You can’t wait for someone else to take action. You don’t need to be perfect. You don’t need to do everything. But you do need to begin. Because the Earth doesn’t need more perfect people, it needs millions of imperfect people who care enough to act with intention everyday. Sources: Klein, Ezra, and Thompson, Derek. Abundance . Simon & Schuster, 18 March 2025 “Gaylord Nelson & Earth Day Origins.” Nelson Earth Day , https://nelsonearthday.net/gaylord-nelson-earth-day-origins/ . Accessed 18 Apr. 2025. Gammon, Katharine. “The Deadly Donora Smog of 1948 Spurred Environmental Protection—But Have We Forgotten the Lesson?” Smithsonian Magazine , 26 Oct. 2018, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/deadly-donora-smog-1948-spurred-environmental-protection-have-we-forgotten-lesson-180970533/ . Accessed 18 Apr. 2025. Lamoreaux, Naomi. “The 1943 Hellish Cloud Was the Most Vivid Warning of L.A.'s Smog Problems to Come.” Smithsonian Magazine , 15 Jan. 2018, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/1943-hellish-cloud-was-most-vivid-warning-las-smog-problems-come-180964119/ . Accessed 18 Apr. 2025. “The Merrimack River: How Revisiting Its History Helps Renew Action.” Forest Society Blog , Society for the Protection of New Hampshire Forests, 26 Sept. 2022, https://www.forestsociety.org/blog-post/merrimack-river-how-revisiting-its-history-helps-renew-action . Accessed 18 Apr. 2025. Pyne, Stephen J. “The Cuyahoga River Caught Fire at Least a Dozen Times, but No One Cared Until 1969.” Smithsonian Magazine , 22 June 2019, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/cuyahoga-river-caught-fire-least-dozen-times-no-one-cared-until-1969-180972444/ . Accessed 18 Apr. 2025. Westervelt, Eric. “How California’s Worst Oil Spill Turned Beaches Black and the Nation Green.” NPR , 28 Jan. 2019, https://www.npr.org/2019/01/28/688219307/how-californias-worst-oil-spill-turned-beaches-black-and-the-nation-green . Accessed 18 Apr. 2025.